for a long moment. âI wish I knew, Saloma. Thatâs always the question we ask as a ministry, and Iâm afraid we donât always find the answer. Alvin was the last person I would have expected to pull something like this.â
Debbieâs ears buzzed as the familyâs conversation continued around her. She heard the questions and speculations through a haze. Even her arms were numb from shock. How could this have happened? Alvin had left for her world? One of the Kneppsâthe family known for never breaking the Ordnungâ was going Englisha ? Heâd never shown the slightest inclination of such a choiceâ¦or had she missed something?
What about his interest in her? Did that mean nothing? Why hadnât she made an effort sooner to contact Alvin through Verna? She should have after all the silence these past months. Had Alvin interpreted her intentions incorrectly? Maybe he thought she wanted him to stay away. But how could he think that after the plain words sheâd spoken to him at Vernaâs wedding?
Loisâs words cut through Debbieâs fog. âIt sounds like a broken heart to me. Thatâs the only thing that might cause a Knepp to stir himself to such effort. And to break the Ordnung on top of it.â
âLois!â Mamm scolded, but Debbie knew they were all looking at her, no doubt thinking she was the cause of this.
âButâ¦Iâ¦â More words wouldnât come so Debbie lowered her gaze and stared at the table.
She could feel everyone staring at her.
The bishop spoke. His voice was kind, but the words cut to her heart. âHave you been toying with Alvinâs heart, Debbie?â
Debbie shook her head. She didnât trust her voice at the moment. How could they think this of her? She wanted to spill out words in her defense, to tell them of the efforts Verna and she had made at the wedding. How theyâd invited Alvin to be a table waiter with her.How sheâd spoken to Alvin afterward and tried to assure him that Paul Wagler meant nothing to her.
âPlease, Daett .â Saloma placed her hand on her husbandâs arm again. âDebbie isnât to blame for whatever Alvin is up to.â
The bishop pressed on. âI could declare I heard someone say that Paul Wagler said something aboutâ¦â Bishop Beiler paused.
Debbie waited a second before prompting, âPaul said what?â
Bishop Beiler took a quick glance around the supper table. âIt might be best not to speak of such things here.â
Lois snorted. âCome on, Daett . What you have to say canât be worse than what Paul says in public for all to hear.â
â Yah , I suppose,â Bishop Beiler allowed. âNone of the Waglers can keep their mouths shut for the most part. And Paul is the worst. Word has it that he let on to Alvin that he wouldnât stand a chance with Debbie.â
âHe was speaking this around?â Saloma appeared horrified. âDebbie had nothing to do with this, Iâm sure.â
They all looked at her again. Debbieâs mind spun. She was still an Englisha girl to them, and she couldnât blame the Beilers for being uncertain about her. What should she say? If Verna were only here, sheâd know. But right now her silence convinced no one, so she blurted out, âI care for Alvin Knepp, and I wouldnât have turned down his interest. In fact, I would have welcomed it! I have no interest in Paul, and he is only saying such things to mess things up between Alvin and me.â
âAre you sure about this, Debbie?â Bishop Beiler regarded her steadily. âIt sounds to me like two of our boys are fighting over the Englisha girl among us. Is this at the bottom of Alvin fleeing the community?â
Debbie was sure sheâd pass out any second. Bishop Beiler had never referred to her as âthe Englisha girlâ before. Sheâd always felt welcome in his home, even if