new handholds, walk again. Simple.
Except only his right hand held, and that for just amoment. Then it, too, slipped out of its shallow niche and he fell on his back on the floor beside the dog bones.
He lay there half stunned, wanting to scream for the unknown horseman to come back, get him outâkill him, even, as long as it was out under the sky. This wouldnât work. Heâd neverâ
No.
Sit up.
Was this his cap, this soft thing under his hand?
Yes. How fortunate. Everything was going to be all right. Finding his cap was a sign of that. He settled it on his head. It hurt where heâd cut himself, but the extra warmth felt good.
He stood up. He stepped to the wall again. With his right hand, he began to feel his way along. Heâd go all the way around the hole like this. Heâd assess the whole surface. Heâd find better handholds, make his left hand work, climb up. He had to, so he would.
Blindly he began, and blindly he went on. The surface of the hole was fairly uniform. It had a couple of bulgesâor maybe just one, he started to worry. Maybe heâd been around once already and was starting again. Hard to tell when all he could see was the little sky above and the blur of dog bones.
A bulge again. This was at least the third time. Despair flooded him, and he dropped his forehead against the out-cropping. After all his mother had done to keep him out of the mine, he was going to die undergroundâ
Pebbles rained down on his back.
âSsss!â
Phin didnât move.
âPhin! You down there?â
He knew that voice! He stepped back, looked up, and saw a round head against the blue. âJimmy?â
4
J IMMY
J immy sagged back, shaking his head. ââOut the back window,â they said, and âDog Hole,â said I. But I didnât believe it! Mikkeleen wouldnât fall in the Dog Hole!â
Phin didnât say anything. He couldnât. The world above was real again, and fear was real, too.
âHow bad you hurt?â Jimmy asked. âCan you climb a rope?â
Phin swallowed. âIâ¦donât think so.â
âI canât haul you up,â Jimmy said. âItâs a dead drop.â
âLadder?â
Jimmy ignored him. âIf I knot it? Could you climb a rope with knots?â
It sounded impossible. âI think so.â
âIâll get one,â Jimmy scrambled to his feet, then leaned down again with a sardonic grin. âDonât go anywhere!â
Phin sagged against the wall. Jimmy. Of course. He couldnât get himself out. Jimmy Lundy could. Wasnât that how it had always been?
Theyâd been inseparable until age seven, when Jimmy went into the breaker. Phin had waited for his own lunch pail, waited to go to work. When it didnât happen, he asked.
âI need your help here,â his mother said. It took him years to see that she was lying.
She wanted him to read to her. Work went easier, she said, with something to think of besides coal-grimed shirts. The books were hard, but she helped him understand what the sentences meant.
âWhoso would be a man must be a noncomformist.â That was from âSelf Reliance,â by Emerson. Phinâs father had come to America because of this essay, and had courted his mother by reading it to her. âWhosoâ meant whoever, she told him. âWouldâ: wants to be. âA manâ was a person grown large, deep, subtle, and strong in character. âNonconformistâ: true to yourself, no matter what other people think.
âAre you a man?â Phin asked his mother. She laughed, rare in those years.
âYou know, Phin, I believe I am! But donât tell anyone.â
He could see her up to her elbows in water, listening as he read. An Irish washerwoman wasnât supposed to read at all, let alone read Emerson. But Mary Chase was free; born that way, kept that way through her own determination.